Cutting Through The Narcissus Syndrome
By P. Bruce Hunter | February 10, 2014
According to Greek myth, Narcissus was the most handsome of men, the son (many said) of a god. Most who gazed upon him fell head over heels in love.
Narcissus knew of his beauty and rejected all of the nymphs trying to court his favour. One day, a frustrated maiden prayed that he might know what it was to love and not have his affections returned. The goddess Artemis, who had been very fond of another scorned maiden, saw her chance and cursed Narcissus.
While drinking from a crystal clear pool, he caught sight of his reflection and became entranced with himself. He remained at the edge of the water, transfixed by his own beauty. Seasons passed and eventually Narcissus died there, a victim of his belief in his own beauty.
I’ll bet you’ve met a few folks (or companies) who suffer from the Narcissus Syndrome!
A while back, I came upon a nice summary of Narcissus symptoms (actually he was speaking about lawyers but it’s still applicable) by Juriscape CEO Harrsion Barnes.
- They are generally preoccupied with fantasies of limitless brilliance, power and success. They are the smartest people in the room.
- They have an exaggerated sense of self-importance that is far from their actual level of achievement.
- They lack empathy and are unwilling or unable to identify with the needs or feelings of others.
- They are envious of those around them with strength they don’t have, and they believe that others are envious of them.
- They require constant admiration and approval.
The worst part about the foregoing attributes is that those exhibiting these types of behaviours are blind to their impact on others - as individuals or as a company. Over time they find themselves alone. Does “Research in Motion” ring a bell?
The Narcissus Syndrome affects large and small companies alike. Entrepreneurial ventures are particularly susceptible because they rely so heavily on the perceptions of the owner/founder. That individual wields two big sticks: the experience acquired while building the company and the ability to effectively squash dissenting opinion. Too often, the company’s actions are directed toward the preconceived notions of the founder with disastrous results.
“It is the nature of these people and organizations to deny the reality of the other’s (the advisor or external environment) world,” wrote the University of Virginia’s Richard Ruth.
“There is an active move to try and destroy the facts supporting an alternate view in service of a soothing return to a narcissistic self-sufficiency.” And therein lies danger!
Here are some thoughts for those attempting to break through with an uncomfortable truth.
- Start with fact(s).
- Be appropriately direct.
- Take the “Narcissists” out of their comfort zone.
Third party, outside-in feedback is key.
In many cases, giving a third-party group the responsibility for conducting confidential, 360 reviews offers valuable and validated feedback. Customers or employees are most often unwilling to provide the kind of direct feedback without the security of anonymity and confidentiality.
Sometimes tact works. Sometimes, you’ve got to use a two-by-four to get attention. The more firmly entrenched the belief, the more difficult it will be to dis-lodge.
Subject experts are a great way to introduce new ideas or infuse knowledge into the mix and start the wheels of change moving. The use of case studies which illuminate similar challenges has the advantage of being both authoritative and non-confrontational.